Logs for jdev
[00:11:47] * Tobias_ joined the chat.
[00:14:49] * Tobias left the chat.
[00:28:07] * Lance left the chat.
[00:55:59] * Lance joined the chat.
[01:15:01] * darkrain_ left the chat.
[01:38:59] * faceprint left the chat.
[03:17:05] * Lance left the chat.
[03:17:21] * Lance joined the chat.
[03:17:25] * Lance left the chat.
[06:25:51] * Tobias_ left the chat.
[06:30:15] * Tobias joined the chat.
[06:32:25] * Alex joined the chat.
[06:42:49] * Tobias left the chat.
[06:53:51] * Tobias joined the chat.
[07:42:43] * Alex left the chat.
[07:42:43] * Alex joined the chat.
[07:52:53] * luca tagliaferri joined the chat.
[08:33:47] * Tobias left the chat.
[08:49:07] * scippio left the chat.
[09:10:35] * Tobias joined the chat.
[09:36:46] * Tobias left the chat.
[09:40:04] * Tobias joined the chat.
[09:43:25] * scippio joined the chat.
[10:36:11] * drасо left the chat.
[10:56:31] * drасо joined the chat.
[11:01:26] * Tobias left the chat.
[11:38:08] * Tobias joined the chat.
[12:22:41] * drасо left the chat.
[12:41:23] * Tobias left the chat.
[13:03:13] * Tobias joined the chat.
[13:16:55] * duck1123 joined the chat.
[13:16:55] * duck1123 left the chat.
[13:18:15] * Tobias left the chat.
[13:20:10] * duck1123 joined the chat.
[13:41:27] * deryni left the chat.
[13:50:48] * Alex left the chat.
[13:55:08] * louiz’ left the chat.
[13:55:23] * louiz’ joined the chat.
[14:20:18] * psa joined the chat.
[14:24:14] * Alex joined the chat.
[14:33:48] * Lance joined the chat.
[14:35:05] * deryni joined the chat.
[14:45:02] * darkrain_ joined the chat.
[14:59:30] * luca tagliaferri left the chat.
[15:00:19] * luca tagliaferri joined the chat.
[15:00:51] * Lance left the chat.
[15:11:32] * Lance joined the chat.
[15:16:02] * Alex left the chat.
[15:17:56] * Alex joined the chat.
[15:28:47] * Tobias joined the chat.
[15:59:23] * Alex left the chat.
[15:59:57] * Alex joined the chat.
[16:04:53] * luca tagliaferri left the chat.
[16:18:38] * waqas joined the chat.
[16:20:06] <waqas> Does anyone have thoughts on this: http://mail.jabber.org/pipermail/jdev/2012-October/089202.html ?
[16:22:27] <Kev> Yes. It's a bit ugly, but you shouldn't go invisible while you're in MUCs.
[16:23:01] <Kev> (In fact, you pretty much shouldn't use privacy lists at all :))
[16:24:03] * Lance left the chat.
[16:24:04] * Lance joined the chat.
[16:26:15] * tofu joined the chat.
[16:29:29] * tofu left the chat.
[16:30:57] <waqas> Kev: I can agree with not using privacy lists :)
[16:32:05] <psa> /me points to http://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0191.html
[16:32:56] * tofu joined the chat.
[16:33:13] * tofu left the chat.
[16:57:22] <Lance> it looks like things should work fine using xep-0186
[16:59:37] <Lance> the only issue I'm seeing is going invisible after joining a muc means you'd have to explicitly leave the muc before disconnecting
[17:00:05] <psa> well, following 186 would still result in sending unavailable when you go invisible, no?
[17:00:38] <Lance> crap, I was just looking in the server handling section
[17:00:56] <waqas> Is there an advantage to clearing directed presence when you go unavailable (but are not disconnected)?
[17:00:58] <psa> yeah
[17:01:29] <psa> I echo what Kev said -- trying to be invisible in a public space like a MUC room is inherently contradictory :)
[17:03:33] <Kev> waqas: So what happens when you then go offline? Does the server then send unavailable only to those people you've sent directed
presence to?
[17:04:51] <Kev> There are certainly ways in which we could engineer the protocol to be more complicated, but right now "When you go invisible
you'll stop appearing online to /everyone/" seems pretty sensible to me. You can resend directed to people you want to afterwards,
and rejoin any MUCS you want to.
[17:05:47] * waqas left the chat.
[17:06:08] * waqas joined the chat.
[17:06:30] <psa> /me nods to Kev
[17:06:32] <Lance> Kev: +1, if a client goes invisible, then it should already know what mucs it has joined
[17:06:50] <Lance> it's not hard to rejoin
[17:07:35] <waqas> Kev: Isn't it more complex to special-case the unavailable broadcast to directed presence sessions when directed presence
is in no other way connected to normal XMPP presence?
[17:08:11] * scippio left the chat.
[17:08:17] <waqas> Because that's what this is at the moment: a special-casing
[17:08:30] <Kev> There has to be a special casing somewhere, though.
[17:08:38] <Kev> Either on unavailable or on logout.
[17:09:04] <Kev> Somewhere there has to be code that says "If the user looks online to anyone, stop it".
[17:09:14] <waqas> On resource disconnect makes more sense to me from a clean-design perspective
[17:12:19] * Alex left the chat.
[17:12:23] <psa> waqas: where were you in 1999? ;-)
[17:12:48] * Alex joined the chat.
[17:17:20] * duck1123 left the chat.
[17:18:32] * duck1123 joined the chat.
[17:18:32] * duck1123 left the chat.
[17:19:31] <waqas> Probably in high school, without a JID :P
[17:19:42] <Kev> Kids these days.
[17:20:23] * duck1123 joined the chat.
[17:21:49] <Lance> well, I still need to flesh the wiki page out a bit later today, but I've thrown my hat in for council now
[17:22:21] <Kev> Cool.
[17:24:23] * Alex left the chat.
[17:24:53] * Alex joined the chat.
[17:48:15] * Alex left the chat.
[18:11:09] * MattJ joined the chat.
[18:13:16] * Lance left the chat.
[18:15:13] * Lance joined the chat.
[18:36:56] * Alex joined the chat.
[18:41:19] * waqas left the chat.
[18:53:41] * Tobias left the chat.
[18:54:42] * Tobias joined the chat.
[19:36:07] * Alex left the chat.
[19:52:00] * vincent_v left the chat.
[19:54:14] * vincent_v joined the chat.
[19:54:16] * Alex joined the chat.
[20:12:50] * luca tagliaferri joined the chat.
[20:31:40] * Alex left the chat.
[20:33:47] * Alex joined the chat.
[20:43:30] * darkrain_ left the chat.
[20:45:20] * Alex left the chat.
[20:46:04] * Alex joined the chat.
[20:46:20] * luca tagliaferri left the chat.
[20:47:31] * Alex left the chat.
[20:47:32] * darkrain_ joined the chat.
[20:48:16] * Alex joined the chat.
[20:56:24] * Alex left the chat.
[21:16:38] * luca tagliaferri joined the chat.
[21:17:02] * psa left the chat.
[21:18:57] * duck1123 left the chat.
[21:19:26] * duck1123 joined the chat.
[21:19:26] * duck1123 left the chat.
[21:21:18] * duck1123 joined the chat.
[21:48:49] * duck1123 left the chat.
[21:55:41] * Tobias left the chat.
[23:40:11] * luca tagliaferri left the chat.
[23:42:50] * Lance left the chat.
[23:53:12] * Lance joined the chat.