Logs for jabber
[00:15:01] * naw joined the chat.
[00:37:07] * NEOhidra left the chat.
[00:45:32] * naw left the chat.
[02:17:46] * aRyo joined the chat.
[02:30:48] * shihabudheen14 joined the chat.
[02:30:49] * shihabudheen14 left the chat.
[02:32:32] * shihabudheen14 joined the chat.
[02:33:02] * shihabudheen14 left the chat.
[02:34:08] * shihabudheen14 joined the chat.
[02:35:49] * shihabudheen14 left the chat.
[03:50:32] * darkrain left the chat.
[04:03:13] * kid joined the chat.
[04:09:01] * aRyo left the chat.
[06:23:39] * gigawatts121 joined the chat.
[06:23:49] * gigawatts121 left the chat.
[06:32:53] * mebs joined the chat.
[06:37:33] * kid left the chat.
[06:37:38] * kid joined the chat.
[06:40:03] * kid left the chat.
[06:40:08] * kid joined the chat.
[06:48:02] * kid left the chat.
[06:48:14] * kid joined the chat.
[07:23:55] * kid left the chat.
[07:54:17] * kid joined the chat.
[09:23:43] * naw joined the chat.
[09:36:23] * خــــ☻ـــو↑↓خـــ♪ـــ♥ــة joined the chat.
[09:38:25] * خــــ☻ـــو↑↓خـــ♪ـــ♥ــة in now known as Kh.
[09:38:42] * Kh left the chat.
[09:59:55] * Lastwebpage joined the chat.
[10:52:37] * Vincent V. left the chat.
[10:53:13] * Vincent V. joined the chat.
[12:09:49] * Vincent V. left the chat.
[12:14:07] * NEOhidra joined the chat.
[12:49:55] * we7tsibe joined the chat.
[12:50:37] * we7tsibe left the chat.
[13:43:49] * kid left the chat.
[13:43:53] * kid joined the chat.
[13:59:24] * darkrain joined the chat.
[14:04:52] * kid left the chat.
[14:04:56] * kid joined the chat.
[14:05:17] * Neustradamus left the chat.
[14:18:09] * MattJ joined the chat.
[14:21:46] * Neustradamus joined the chat.
[15:03:21] * kid left the chat.
[15:03:31] * kid joined the chat.
[15:04:49] * kid left the chat.
[15:04:53] * kid joined the chat.
[15:07:23] * kid left the chat.
[15:07:27] * kid joined the chat.
[15:09:02] * kid left the chat.
[15:09:06] * kid joined the chat.
[15:52:24] * dynam1te joined the chat.
[16:06:49] * kid left the chat.
[16:30:02] * Jason "Manbeard" Al-Mansor joined the chat.
[16:30:19] * Jason "Manbeard" Al-Mansor left the chat.
[16:33:17] * Loveshore joined the chat.
[16:33:17] * Loveshore left the chat.
[16:34:36] * Loveshore joined the chat.
[16:34:59] * Loveshore left the chat.
[16:35:19] * Loveshore joined the chat.
[16:35:34] * Loveshore left the chat.
[16:36:27] * Loveshore joined the chat.
[16:36:28] * Loveshore left the chat.
[16:37:09] * Loveshore joined the chat.
[16:40:18] * Loveshore left the chat.
[16:41:12] * Kev left the chat.
[16:42:12] * Kev joined the chat.
[16:50:05] * Kev left the chat.
[16:50:21] * Kev joined the chat.
[16:55:28] * Link Mauve left the chat.
[16:59:41] * Link Mauve joined the chat.
[17:14:37] * yuppinturic joined the chat.
[17:35:11] * naw left the chat.
[17:42:35] * Neustradamus left the chat.
[18:27:23] * mati joined the chat.
[18:33:45] <mati> Hi, short question: when doing a legacy SSL connection (typically port 5223) what host should I connect to? the one thats
indicated by the A/AAAA record or the one indicated by the xmpp-client SRV record?
[18:34:47] <Kev> I'm assuming you're doing this because you want to find if the host supports 5223, not because you're using this as the best
connection method.
[18:34:59] <mati> Kev, yes, exactly
[18:35:15] <Kev> Any client that *requires* 5223 is not going to be doing SRV lookups (I assert), and will just be looking at the A.
[18:35:32] <Kev> *However*, people can still do manual host setup in lots of clients.
[18:35:48] <mati> Kev, let me refine the statement a bit
[18:36:04] <Kev> So I would have thought that, despite it not being what any clients that require 5223 would be doing, using the SRV result
is your best chance of getting 5223 to work.
[18:36:12] <mati> I want to find if the server supports legacy SSL. I already know the port (because I ask for it)
[18:37:11] <mati> but I bet 99% of the clients out there use the same method
[18:37:45] <Kev> You could always do both :)
[18:40:30] <mati> I guess I will ask a few client-devs for that
[18:40:53] <mati> Kev, i.e. gajim also has a "use legacy SSL" button, which does not force you to configure a host or so
[18:41:03] <Kev> Right.
[18:41:27] <Kev> You've got two types of clients
1) Clients that are so old and broken they require 5223
2) Modern clients that allow you to force 5223 anyway
[18:41:43] <Kev> (I use '5223' to mean 'legacy protocol over a TLS/SSL socket')
[18:41:59] <Kev> Any (1) clients won't be doing SRV, and so will need the hostname to match the A.
[18:42:13] <Kev> Whereas it wouldn't surprise me if (2) will use the SRV results.
[18:42:36] <Kev> [Of course, you also have clients that don't do 5223 at all, but that's not relevant]
[18:54:12] <mati> Kev, hmm
[18:54:23] <mati> I will research a bit on what clients do :-)
[19:14:19] * Kev left the chat.
[19:14:31] * Kev joined the chat.
[19:27:01] * yuppinturic left the chat.
[19:32:44] <mati> Kev, one more question: Is IBR almost never/sometimes/often/always advertised as a stream feature ( http://xmpp.org/registrar/stream-features.html
)?
[19:32:58] <Kev> Almost never, I imagine.
[19:33:17] <Kev> Not sure, though.
[19:33:32] <Kev> Is there a stream feature designated for it?
[19:33:53] * look-K-me-I-in-D-my-O-eyes joined the chat.
[19:34:10] <Kev> Oh, yes, since 2003.
[19:34:20] <Kev> So maybe they do offer - should be easy to find a couple of servers to check against.
[19:34:35] <mati> Kev, ... thats what I'm doing right now :-)
[19:34:43] <mati> I mean: will be doing in a moment
[19:35:10] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:35:10] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:35:28] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:35:28] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:35:57] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:35:59] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:36:13] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:36:13] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:36:17] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:36:17] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:36:34] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:36:34] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:37:10] <mati> hmm, newer ejabberd-versions seem to do it
[19:38:04] <mati> Kev, Q: do you know of a public instance of M-Link (thats what jabber.org runs, right?) that allows IBR?
[19:38:17] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:38:32] <Kev> M-Link doesn't support IBR for account provisioning (jabber.org supports IBR for password changing).
[19:40:31] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:41:25] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:41:36] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:41:38] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:41:38] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:41:40] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:41:40] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:42:01] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:44:09] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:44:24] * Lolo joined the chat.
[19:45:25] * Lolo left the chat.
[19:49:13] * naw joined the chat.
[19:50:01] * Tobias joined the chat.
[19:57:15] * look-K-me-I-in-D-my-O-eyes left the chat.
[20:14:43] <mati> Kev, is the inclusion of stream features optional? or would you consider it a bug if IBR is not advertised as stream-feature
even if its in fact supported?
[20:15:34] <Kev> XEP-0077 says MAY, which is synonymous with OPTIONAL.
[20:16:20] <mati> ok, so there is no real way of telling
[20:16:53] <mati> (damn :-()
[20:18:09] <mati> Kev, or do you think I should file a bugreport with Prosody and Tigase?
[20:20:49] * bjk joined the chat.
[20:22:28] <bjk> does anyone else have problems with jabber.org retaining user settings? settings like "store mesages received while offline?",
etc..
[20:26:19] * Augusto Stoffel joined the chat.
[20:26:19] * Augusto Stoffel left the chat.
[20:30:36] * bjk left the chat.
[20:44:09] * Vincent V. joined the chat.
[20:55:00] <Kev> mati: I don't think it's a bug, really. You could file an enhancement request :)
[21:19:27] * Tobias left the chat.
[21:24:06] * Tobias joined the chat.
[21:26:09] * Vincent V. left the chat.
[21:29:26] * schmutz joined the chat.
[21:29:57] * schmutz left the chat.
[21:30:15] * Vincent V. joined the chat.
[21:32:39] * Tobias left the chat.
[21:37:42] * Neustradamus joined the chat.
[21:55:25] * Lastwebpage left the chat.
[22:02:48] * Tobias joined the chat.
[22:16:15] * MattJ left the chat.
[22:35:56] * Vincent V. left the chat.
[22:46:57] * mati left the chat.
[22:51:38] * Tobias left the chat.
[23:33:09] * NEOhidra left the chat.
[23:48:42] * naw left the chat.
[23:55:55] * Kev left the chat.